Supreme Court sides with Entebbe man in land fight with businessman Wavamunno

The Supreme Court has dealt a huge blow to prominent businessman Gordon Wavamunno after it ruled that he could not evict Sekyanzi Sempijja, a bricklayer, from a piece of land in Entebbe that he claims is his.

Wavamunno is one of Uganda’s best-known businessmen, and in the 1970s, he founded Spear Motors, a Mercedes-Benz dealership. Later, he started a television station and other businesses, including a mineral water bottling company.

The Supreme Court set aside a 2020 Court of Appeal ruling that had ruled in Wavamunno’s favour, and it restored the orders of the High Court.

The dispute began in 2007, when Sempijja sued Wavamunno in the Chief Magistrate’s Court at Entebbe. He said Wavamunno had grabbed and unlawfully sold off his “kibanja”, which is an unregistered interest in land.

The plot sits on mailo land in Bufulu village, Katabi Sub-County, Wakiso District.

Sempijja claimed the plot measured about two acres, and he inherited the land when his father, the late George Sempijja, died in 1985.

Sempijja asked the court for vacant possession, general and exemplary damages, interest and costs.

Wavamunno denied the claim. He told the court he had been the registered owner of the mailo land since 24 December 1984. He said the land was empty until Sempijja started digging up soil from it.

He also said the two men had settled the matter themselves. He said on January 23, 2007, they signed an agreement in which Sempijja promised to stop all activity on the land and in return, Wavamunno agreed to pay him  Shs 175,000 to move his bricks off the plot.

Wavamunno added that he had since sold the land to a third party, Winfred Lalani.

The Entebbe Chief Magistrates Court heard the case in full and sided with Sempijja. It found that his father had used the plot openly for more than 12 years before he died, and that nobody from Wavamunno’s side had stopped him.

It ordered Wavamunno to compensate Sempijja as a bona fide occupant and awarded him Shs 3 million in general damages and the costs of the suit.

Wavamunno appealed to the High Court’s Land Division, which also sided with Sempijja.

It noted that Sempijja was about 11 years old when his father died, and that he inherited the plot in 1986. It added the father’s years on the land to Sempijja’s own years there.

Together, they came to more than 12 years before the Constitution came into force on October 8, 1995.

Not satisfied, Wavamunno took the matter to the Court of Appeal, and this time he won.

The three justices there said a person must have occupied the land for 12 continuous years before October 1995 to qualify.

By their count, Sempijja had been on the land for only 10 of those years. They also said his father could not have been a bona fide occupant, because the law that created that status did not exist when he died.

Sempijja did not give up and petitioned the Supreme Court in July 2023.

The Supreme Court narrowed the case to one question. It asked: “Was Sempijja a bona fide occupant of the land?”

To qualify as a bona fide occupant, Sempijja had to prove that he had lived on the land for more than 12 years before the promulgation of the 1995 Constitution.

Sempijja was represented by lawyers Isa Kavuma and Abubaker Ssemagulu of Luzige, Lubega, Kavuma and Company Advocates, while Wavamunno was represented by Martin Kakuru of Ligomarc Advocates.

Both sides asked to rely on their written submissions instead of arguing in person, and the court agreed.

Sempijja’s lawyers said the Court of Appeal was wrong to treat his interest as separate from his father’s. They argued that the law looks at the interest in the land, not at who happens to hold it.

They pointed to section 29(5) of the Land Act, which protects anyone who “purchased or otherwise acquired the interest” of a qualified bona fide occupant.

They also said that bona fide occupants already existed in practice before 1995. In their words, the Constitution and the Land Act “simply formally recognised their rights and/or interests in the land”.

Wavamunno’s side said the Court of Appeal got it right. His lawyer argued that before October 8, 1995, there was no term  ‘bonafide occupant’ in our laws. That meant no such right existed, and Sempijja’s father could not pass on something he never had.

On the facts, Wavamunno’s side said Sempijja himself had been on the land for only 10 years before the Constitution came into force.

KCCA ordered to pay contractor over Shs1.3 bn for inflating costs in drainage channels dispute

Justice Muzamiru Kibeedi wrote the lead judgment, and the other four justices agreed with him.

He began by admitting that the Court of Appeal had a point on the strict wording of the law.

He wrote that the Land Act of 1998 “did not have retrospective application,” adding that Sempijja could only inherit what his father had at the time of his death in 1985.

Justice Kibeedi said people like Sempijja’s face the risk of automatic extinction of their inheritance on the sole ground of the demise of their benefactors before October 1995.

He asked whether Parliament could really have meant to take away the security of occupancy that such families already enjoyed.

To answer that, he looked at the history of land law. He said that under the Limitation Act, which dates from 1959, a person who occupies land openly for more than 12 years is protected from being thrown off it.

Justice Kibeedi discovered that Idi Amin’s Land Reform Decree of 1975 did not repeal that protection.

So when Sempijja’s father died in 1985, he said, “his interest in the suit land which he had occupied for over 12 years was by adverse possession”.

Adverse possession means holding land openly for years without the owner stopping you.

“That is the same interest that [Sempijja] inherited from his father,” he said.

Justice Kibeedi then turned to the Constitution, noting that Article 237(8) says lawful or bona fide occupants of mailo, freehold or leasehold land “shall enjoy security of occupancy on the land”.

He said the Constitution was simply acknowledging already existing occupancy.

“What matters is not the name but the substance of the occupancy,” he said.

Justice Kibeedi argued that the Land Act’s definition of a bona fide occupant, which asks for 12 years of use before the Constitution, was not exhaustive because it did not clearly cover people like Sempijja.

He said the Court of Appeal’s strict approach would not only perpetuate the historical injustice that was intended to be redressed by Article 237(8) and (9) of the Constitution, but would also go against what the framers wanted.

Justice Kibeedi said, “extinguishing of the interest of persons in occupancy of the registered lands was not one of the discernible objectives of the legal provisions”.

In conclusion, he said Sempijja was the bona fide occupant on the contested land.

Justice Catherine Bamugemereire agreed with Justice Kibeedi’s conclusion, noting that the magistrate and the High Court had both accepted that planting trees and perennial crops proved the land had been used continuously.

She said the Court of Appeal should not have departed from those findings without good reason. She also said it paid too much attention to the years Sempijja himself spent on the land.

Justices Elizabeth Musoke, Stephen Musota and Monica Mugenyi each agreed with Justice Kibeedi.

The ruling means Sempijja’s Shs 3 million award stands, but also, Wavamunno must compensate Sempijja for his interest as a bona fide occupant, at a value to be set by the Chief Government Valuer.

The final amount Sempijja will get will depend on that valuation.

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Social media & sharing icons powered by UltimatelySocial